This movie was 90s-2000s and I believe was on Nickelodeon, maybe a direct to TV movie?

Major scene I remember was 2 teenagers/kids playing football inside the house and the toilet gets broken. The toilet gets replaced the next day or something, but over time the kids start realizing the parents are either different or missing. Then they find the toilet replacement is a scheme to kidnap parents and adults (I think everywhere, but maybe just their parents). And there may have been some replacement of the parents with these toilet people?

Idk, was this a childhood fever dream or did this exist to anyone else?