Not blood creek great movie btw… I remember a scene where he’s captured the 2 girls, hangs them up in the barn, sharpens some type of knife… puts some type of mask of one of the girls heads and cuts her catching the blood in a bucket. In a later scene I think they find the mask with the head inside… hope this helps
Maybe: Jug Face (2013) – http://www.imdb.com/title/tt2620736/
not Jug Face either see my comments to the Blood Creek suggestion… thanks and please keep trying
Blood Creek?
http://youtu.be/7mJNYSV-OXc
Not blood creek great movie btw… I remember a scene where he’s captured the 2 girls, hangs them up in the barn, sharpens some type of knife… puts some type of mask of one of the girls heads and cuts her catching the blood in a bucket. In a later scene I think they find the mask with the head inside… hope this helps
https://irememberthismovie.com/2000-or-newer-horror-creature-lives-in-a-cellar-on-a-farm