I remember a scene where he’s captured the 2 girls, hangs them up in the barn, sharpens some type of knife… puts some type of mask of one of the girls heads and cuts her catching the blood in a bucket. In a later scene I think they find the mask with the head inside…
Babysitter Wanted (2008)?
not this one either
Maybe: Blood Harvest (1987) – http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0092671/
definitely not Blood Harvest, much newer different story
my guess is “Texas Chainsaw” or some other version of it, though I don’t want to watch it again to check. lol
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Texas_Chainsaw_3D
none of the Texas chainsaw movies either
Bereavement (2010)?
not this one either
it seems that if whatevers is in the cellar isn’t fed it turns into some type of demon/monster and kills everyone…. hope that might help
Evil Offspring (2009)?
not that one either, thanks for trying
The Hamiltons?
https://irememberthismovie.com/2000-or-newer-horror-creature-lives-in-a-cellar-on-a-farm